For me personally, I don't see AI "art" as art because it's not made by a person. It's made off of an algorithm trained to notice patterns in static based on keywords. There's no true thoughts behind why things were done the way they were in a piece. Nor do I believe one can be an AI artist. The person putting the prompts in is not an artist. The AI is the artist. The prompter is the commissioner and the AI is the artist being commissioned. The "skill" of knowing what you type as a prompt is the same skill of knowing how to properly communicate to an artist what you want. To me a drawing made by a toddler will always have more soul than a drawing someone prompted a computer to make. A child learning to draw more than a stick figure is more work towards art than the "artists" who only make AI "art".
Would you not say thats the same as using a digital drawing tablet? You can study traditional painting for years and develop a personal technique with your own brushes and even mix your own unique paint. However when you use a digital drawing tool you are getting perfect brush strokes created by pre-made brushes using simulated paint. I don't think anyone here would argue that digital painting is not a valid form of art through; its not the same, but they are both valid and allow you to focus on different things with different results.As both a traditional and digital artist, I can tell you that you're not even close. The main difference between traditional and digital art is the ability to do certain things easier and faster, but there is a steep learning curve. You have to study digital painting the same way you have to study traditional; it can take years and both offer many different type of tools that take time to learn. Even getting "perfect brush strokes" in digital art can take a lot of time to accomplish. Digital art is just another medium of art. You still have to understand your craft to make it.
AI image prompting removes the need for theory, for all you need is to give it instructions on what it is you want, the only bit of theory around it is how to tell the AI what you want. The AI is what's providing most of the visual appeal. This is the line where tools turn to automation.AI art doesn't understand theory nor do most that push for it being used for profit. That's why when you look closer to at a lot of AI art, no matter how pretty at first glance, you can start seeing the flaws and illogical attributes in it.
A traditional artist being forced to use a drawing tablet doesn't suddenly lose their ability to draw and create art, just like how a digital artist being forced to use a pencil doesn't lose theirs. You take the trained algorithm away from an AI "artist", they can no longer create their art without another algorithm and other people's art.










Posts: 100/24hrs

















