What is the greatest album of all time? - © ∙ Music - MelonLand Forum

• What is the greatest album of all time?
  Posted by Melooon on 07 Feb, 2023 21:52
• I don't mean your personal favourite! I mean objectively, what is the greatest album ever made 
• #1 Reply
  Posted by bugholder's epiphany on 07 Feb, 2023 22:00
• Might be a cliched answer but I'm tempted to say Pink Floyd's Dark Side Of The Moon. All of the tracks are consistently great and wonderful to me!
• #2 Reply
  Posted by dotmidi on 15 Feb, 2023 19:10
• When we are talking from an Objective standpoint I think it would have to be something that considerably influenced a lot of the music genre as a whole so .. hmm.. I'll have to think this one out
  
  I'd have to say that would be the Hunky Dory album by David Bowie I feel it was extremely influential. OR maybe something to do with The Stooges, just certain bands that were huge influences.
   (with my preferences aside i have my own opinions of "the greatest albums")
• #3 Reply
  Posted by Commodorn on 15 Feb, 2023 19:23
• I.. uhm.. well.. if...
  
  if I were to decide going by how influential, varied, and experimental an album is, I'd say the white album from The Beatles first and "Q: Are we not men? A: We are Devo!" second. That's just how I feel this very moment, though.
• #4 Reply
  Posted by dotmidi on 15 Feb, 2023 19:59
• Quote from: Commodorn on 15 Feb, 2023 19:23

  I.. uhm.. well.. if...
  
  if I were to decide going by how influential, varied, and experimental an album is, I'd say the white album from The Beatles first and "Q: Are we not men? A: We are Devo!" second. That's just how I feel this very moment, though.
  

  
  Beatles was definitely one of my runner ups, I agree. They are extremely influential to the generations past them.
• #5 Reply
  Posted by appleAlc on 15 Feb, 2023 20:28
• I would say perhaps Pink Floyd's The Wall, in terms of both good and influential
• #6 Reply
  Posted by Memory on 16 Feb, 2023 00:51
• You're all overlooking the truly greatest album: Weird Al's "Mandatory Fun".
  
  But for realsies, I'm not qualified to weigh in on an objectively best album. My tastes in music are arguably not good.