2 gif icons linking to my lore page and I'd like to know which one is nicer

[Rubbereon]

I couldn't find a specific icon for my nav, so I opted to make it myself, I'm satisfied with the results except that I can't decide which one I like better.


^Be aware that I will most likely delete one of the gifs so there'll be a dead link, no idea if I should edit the post when that happens.
Now, the 2 gifs again, except only their last frame to make it easier to compare:


It's palette based, so yeah the water will either get yellow just like the stars (which thankfully ain't too visible anyway you probably wouldn't have noticed if I hadn't posted the static frames) or the stars will get white which I personally find not as pretty, but feel it makes sense if compared to real stars.

Feel free to tell me what you all think! 

[TheFrugalGamer]

Personally I like the yellow. I'm a fan of limited palettes because I work in them a lot, and I love the color-mixing effect that dithering can have at low resolutions. Especially because you like the stars yellow more, and the water on the planet isn't as noticeable because of that dithering effect. It just reads as "white" to most eyes.