Artifacts Gallery Guilds Search Wiki Login Register

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register. - Thinking of joining?
Autumn, 18 Nov 2026 - @908.83
Forum Activity: Four Stars Random | Recent Posts | Guild Recents
News: :defrag: Lo and Behold :defrag: Guild Events: Perils & Princesses Character Creation
+  MelonLand Forum
|-+  Da Web Revival
| |-+  ✁ ∙ Web Crafting
| | |-+  Forum Software


« previous next »
Pages: [1] Print Embed
Author Topic: Forum Software  (Read 393 times)
ArtificialAnima
Casual Poster ⚓︎
*
View Profile WWW


She/They
⛺︎ My Room
Matrix: Chat!
Itch.io: My Games
RSS: RSS
OS: NixOS

Artifacts:
First 1000 Members!Joined 2023!
« on: Autumn, 10 Nov 2026 @348 » Embed

I wanna host my own forums for a couple things and I've been looking at the options, and they all kinda have problems.

  • Simple Machines Forum: This is the one that MelonLand uses, so that's neat. Newer versions of it are full of AI now, though: here's their AGENTS.md file. So, like, I can't actually trust it to continue to be good, despite how nostalgic it is.
  • phpBB: Another PHP-based forum. (I feel like the old Minecraft forums used to use this?) They don't seem to use as much AI as SMF seems to, but it has shown up in some commits, ex. this one, and they don't have a policy about it that I could find.
  • Discourse: This feels corporate as fuck and I hate looking at it and I hate how everything is organized into tags and categories instead of boards and they also use AI so, like, no.
  • Flarum: Does the same thing that Discourse does where it's tag-based instead of board-based, and they also seem to have a permissive AI policy.

And then also some others that have similar problems, or that seem to no longer be actively maintained, or that cost money (xenforo).

Should I just deal with SMF (or phpBB) being vibecoded? That seems like my only option.

Logged

https://signalgarden.net/88x31.gif
nobo
Sr. Member ⚓︎
****
View Profile WWWArt


drainnnn
⛺︎ My Room
StatusCafe: nobo
iMood: nobo
RSS: RSS
OS: LUNIX

Guild Memberships:
Artifacts:
Memento moriMoon CheeseFirst 1000 Members!Joined 2023!
« Reply #1 on: Autumn, 10 Nov 2026 @374 » Toggle Font Embed

At this point you have to code the software yourself from the ground up if not using AI at all is important to you. That's just the state of software right now. I don't particularly like it either and if I could press a button and we could go back to how it was before, I would gladly press the button. But the reality of the world we live in now is just the reality. Everyone is using AI in some capacity to build their software now. I hate it as much as you.

But... coding a forum and building a community are two completely different beasts. For most people one of these probably detracts from how much energy they are putting into the other. And most successful forum operators over the years have not been the people who wrote the software.

Melonland is an outlier. Melon is a prodigy of sorts. Most people are just using whatever facilitates their community.

Many times there were things they hated about the software so they would modify it to their liking, which is probably a better way to think of it. If the goal is to build a community then you need to have something people want to use firstly.

In my opinion the most successful modern forums that aren't paying an absurd xenforo subsciption are all discourse boards.

There are some cool discourse forums. You can configure it in a lot of ways, although I tend to agree with you that the default of grouping by tag instead of board is not appealing.

https://forum.defold.com/ -- This is discourse forum of a game enigne I used to use.
https://boards.straightdope.com/ -- An old forum from the 90s that updated their software to Discourse a few years ago.

You can see how these different organizations have customized it to suit what they're trying to do.

If you think of a "category" and a "board" as being the same thing, it kind of makes sense. I bet you can tweak it to where the views dont mix the threads and then edit the software to use the word "board" instead of category, and it would effectively be the same.

Anyway that's my :2cents:

Logged

Drain is about loss and gain; it could be good or bad.
You could be drained of energy or you could drain something to gain energy.

Artifact Swap: Spoon [Dirty]Dropped Sucker
Peri L'Flamme, Towerkin of Magma
Casual Poster
*
View Profile WWWArt


i miss my buddies
⛺︎ My Room
SpaceHey: Friend Me!
iMood: noDisco_Here
Itch.io: My Games
OS: Windows 11

Guild Memberships:
Artifacts:
A Real Digital Messenger PaperJoined 2024!
« Reply #2 on: Autumn, 10 Nov 2026 @406 » Toggle Font Embed

Newer versions of it are full of AI now, though: here's their AGENTS.md file. So, like, I can't actually trust it to continue to be good, despite how nostalgic it is.

that is just an instruction file FOR llms, though? just because its there doesn't mean the services have gAI IN them. im not the one to defend llms and im not like the archgod of knowledge on llms, but "theres an ai agent file so its full of ai" seems kind of misguided...

Logged

I Guess I'll Have To Change My Plan
https://i.imgur.com/rJDPIet.gif
https://i.imgur.com/MYpzmwF.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/YzAasAA.png
https://i.imgur.com/R1yQ8T6.gif
ThunderPerfectWitchcraft
Hero Member ⚓︎
*****
View Profile WWWArt


Here be dragons
⛺︎ My Room

Artifacts:
Visited on Melon's 10th Anniversary!I got robbed by Dan Q on Melonland!Great Posts PacmanThanks for being rad!First 1000 Members!Joined 2023!
« Reply #3 on: Autumn, 10 Nov 2026 @416 » Embed

When you use a computer and contemporary software, you have to expect that your software is partially done with AI, even if you take some lengths to avoid it (your OS, or parts of it; drivers; userland software that you maybe don't even install knowingly; your web/php/database-server - and even projects that are explicitly anti AI might still get commits that go in undetected). Note: I'm not especially thrilled about this, either. In the end, if you want a given piece of software to be human-made for sure, you'll have to code it yourself nowadays.

I'd always a soft spot for MyBB. Dunno about its AI policy.

Logged

Dan Q
Hero Member ⚓︎
*****
View Profile WWWArt


I have no idea what I am doing
⛺︎ My Room
RSS: RSS

Guild Memberships:
Artifacts:
Caught by RubbereonThe Worm is creeping around Melonland profiles!Dan Q Cruisin'I DIDN'T meet Dan Q on Melonland!Visited on Melon's 10th Anniversary!
« Reply #4 on: Autumn, 10 Nov 2026 @492 » Toggle Font Embed

that is just an instruction file FOR llms, though?

This is true. The existence of this file doesn't necessarily mean that they're vibecoding it. In fact, the file explicitly instructs LLMs to announce when they are being used in their commit messages, which is better than some projects. (Obviously that instruction might be disregarded by a badly-behaved LLM or by the human that's operating it, but it's guidance, like a code of conduct is).

Thanks for that directive we can see some examples of LLM use in the project. E.g. here's a backmerge that was Claude-assisted. Aside from merge conflict handling, it looks like they've mostly (declared that they've) used LLMs for test generation and documenting tests. Which I can sympathise with at least a little: implementing automated regression testing is a thankless job and one that clankers can sometimes do a not-too-bad job of, so long as your intention is to treat your existing codebase as bug-free and raise a test failure if behaviour diverges from that in future.

It looks like SMF started using - or at least, started recording use - of AI tooling in July of this year. So if SMF's otherwise the right tool for you but you absolutely don't want any known-AI-authored code, you could fork version 2.1.7 (for context: 2.1.8 only just came out, so we're not talking about a huge downgrade).

Logged

https://danq.me/_q26t/badges/dan-q-88x31-lighter.gif https://danq.me/_q26t/badges/dan-q-88x31-peekaboo-scroller.gif https://beige-buttons.danq.dev/beige-buttons-88x31.gif https://embed-html.danq.dev/embed-html-88x31.gif https://origami.danq.dev/88x31.gif https://skelly.monster/dem-bones-88x31.gif

Artifact Swap: Pink ham-ham rangerPolyamorousI met Dan Q on Melonland!shoeJoined 2025!cinnamoroll
Dan Q
Hero Member ⚓︎
*****
View Profile WWWArt


I have no idea what I am doing
⛺︎ My Room
RSS: RSS

Guild Memberships:
Artifacts:
Caught by RubbereonThe Worm is creeping around Melonland profiles!Dan Q Cruisin'I DIDN'T meet Dan Q on Melonland!Visited on Melon's 10th Anniversary!
« Reply #5 on: Autumn, 10 Nov 2026 @495 » Toggle Font Embed

When you use a computer and contemporary software, you have to expect that your software is partially done with AI, even if you take some lengths to avoid it

And yes, this is also true nowadays, for better or worse.

A huge number of security vulnerabilities nowadays are discovered by huge expensive LLM farms (and then, often, overblown to hell like php2shell!). The patched versions of these software tools wouldn't exist without AI, and in many cases it's now unsafe to use older versions because, well, the vulnerabilities are known.

Even if AI wasn't used to write the patch, it was used to discover the vulnerability that lead to the writing of the patch... so yeah, it's pretty-much impossible to avoid "AI assisted" software nowadays.

Not to be defeatist, of course. You can absolutely take your own stand on what software you support the development of, and what software you create. But the horse is well and truly out of the stable as far as trying to avoid anything that's been touched by GenAI, now.

Logged

https://danq.me/_q26t/badges/dan-q-88x31-lighter.gif https://danq.me/_q26t/badges/dan-q-88x31-peekaboo-scroller.gif https://beige-buttons.danq.dev/beige-buttons-88x31.gif https://embed-html.danq.dev/embed-html-88x31.gif https://origami.danq.dev/88x31.gif https://skelly.monster/dem-bones-88x31.gif

Artifact Swap: Pink ham-ham rangerPolyamorousI met Dan Q on Melonland!shoeJoined 2025!cinnamoroll
lakes
Hero Member ⚓︎
*****
View Profile WWW


⛺︎ My Room
XMPP: Chat!
RSS: RSS

Guild Memberships:
Artifacts:
Potion of Infinite Leg HealthVisited on Melon's 10th Anniversary!Joined 2025!
« Reply #6 on: Autumn, 10 Nov 2026 @668 » Embed

If it makes you feel better, the AI-free FOSS alternatives list on codeberg currently recommend punBB. But I can't speak for the quality and it could always update from not having an official policy to having a permissive policy, since that's kinda what happened with Flarum.
I'd recommend going for stuff with an Anti-AI policy on the list if you absolutely wanna be sure that it doesn't use LLMs. I sympathize with everyone saying that you have to assume that other people's software uses LLMs for commits and things like that and yeah, that's true. But you also gotta realize some developers don't like this either and will announce whether or not they allow LLMs in the commits.

That said, I don't think software that uses LLMs in some way is that easy or even possible for most people to completely avoid, especially since some programs with an anti-LLM policy still have dependencies that use LLMs. The only way I think you can avoid it completely is if you use an extremely niche operating system with an anti-LLM policy like HaikuOS or CoffeeBSD and either only use the default software or use a very small selection of software. No Linux because even though it's not as bad as Windows or MacOS in that regard and some individual distros have taken a stand against LLMs, they're still allowing LLM-commits for the kernel itself. I feel like even if you did manage to avoid these softwares completely, you'd have to make a lot of sacrifices just because of how many developers in mainstream or semi-mainstream projects are adopting it. So the projects that don't use it tend to be smaller and less widely supported which sucks. So it's up to you when it is and isn't a dealbreaker. For example, I switched to using ChiPass over KeepassXC & use Librewolf instead of Firefox/Waterfox, but I still use RSS Guard, qBittorrent and Linux.

« Last Edit: Autumn, 10 Nov 2026 @776 by lakes » Logged

https://i.ibb.co/gbj9yhcZ/userbar-1.pnghttps://i.ibb.co/C3KKzjyx/Computeruser.png
https://i.ibb.co/zhKYtXts/Librebar-X.pnghttps://i.ibb.co/b5mC7H6H/DVDUser.png
https://i.ibb.co/GfCkM0g1/soulseekuserbar.pnghttps://i.ibb.co/0jRYyw7R/Trash-User.png
https://i.ibb.co/gLNfFjqc/098.pnghttps://i.ibb.co/QjqVW8xT/xfceuserbar.png
Pages: [1] Print Embed 
« previous next »
 

Melonking.Net © Always and ever was! SMF © 2021 | Privacy Notice | Send Feedback | Supporters ♥ Guide | Rules | Whos a Mod? | RSS | WAP | Mobile


MelonLand Badges and Other Melon Sites!

MelonLand Project! Visit the MelonLand Forum! Support the Forum
Visit Melonking.Net! Visit the Gif Gallery! Pixel Sea TamaNOTchi
@000 Melon
Land
Forum Art Hub Chat Webring Explore Random Recent Tenement Arcade Want to Login or Join ? Web Craft Guide Graphic Catalogue Wiki Help I'm Lost! Link Land Newsletters Image Stream Minecraft: Online
Zap!
Passport Sites tamaNOTchi Asatte Add your site?
Aero Archive Onio Cafe 32 Bit Cafe Status Cafe