I wonder if a part of the yearning for the old Internet by younger folks who didn't experience it is a by-product of general burnout on the modern day Internet. I was more or less around for the old Internet (born in '87, we got Internet in the house in the mid-late 90s), so when I browse forums like Melonland it's definitely a nostalgic experience that I can relate to, but it's also an escape from the deluge of slop that comes with modern Internet access. I feel like places like Melonland and small, HTML made websites are protected spaces with no tracking or algorithms to try and tell you what you like or sell you something and it's very refreshing to be a part of.