A paganism related website I run into over 15 years ago had a very catchy tagline and I still remembered it. Decided to look it up and oh, some of this stuff is still online! I grabbed some related retro graphics while I was there.
Dividers:








(Lithuanian)
Aphrodite Anadyomene:

Asherah:

Astarte:

Harpy or similar:

Canaanite woman:

Cypriot goddess:

Earth goddess:

Italian goddess:

Seated Woman of Çatalhöyük:

Venus figure from France:

Venus of Willendorf:

Thor's hammer:

Futhark runes:

Permian (Komi and Udmurt people) goddesses:



Ob-Ugric... something:

Danish fertility figures:

Labrys:

Ziggurat:

Not sure what this is. From Kabbalah?:

In the center is a "giant's garden", a Finnish Troy town. At the sides, Ob-Ugric costume for something I'm not sure of:

Modern imagination of a type of Finnish pagan altar:

Siberian bear ritual:

Sword decoration:

Teepee-like structure:

Medieval violence?:

Satanism:


A Christian bonus, Yahweh and Mary:


And Templars:


If anyone has more pagan-related graphics, I'd love to see.