Thoughts on Necrothreads

[TheFrugalGamer]

So I've been thinking about this lately as I read through threads, and realized that each forum probably has their own rules about it.

"Necrothreads" for those who haven't heard the term are forum threads that are open but haven't been commented on in a long time, so they've fallen further down in the thread listing.

What is Melonland's policy on commenting on old threads? Does it bother you, or do you think it's fine? Do you think it's weird when someone shows up and comments on a thread that's been sitting untouched for over a year?

[Melooon]

The official stance is that this forum promotes and encourages posting on old threads - old-discussing warnings should be disabled? - A big part of why I wanted to create a forum was to allow a slow form of discussion, with days or even months between each post, and maybe we are now at a point where there could be years between posts ^^

So feel free to post on any anything you like

[dotmidi]

"Necrothreads" for those who haven't heard the term are forum threads that are open but haven't been commented on in a long time, so they've fallen further down in the thread listing.

This reminds me of the fact that quite recently I have been very invested in reading some pretty old forum posts on the imood website..
so much so that I completely forgot the fact that most of them were written in 2001 or so

Honestly, most people nowadays dont mind since it lets them in on insight of the kind of people on the site awhile ago! especially since a lot of us are keen on slow increment of media and slowed discussion. people are very used to rapid-content and "relevancy" of subjects, which personally i think is not what this side of the web should be like.
 Once an open discussion, always an open discussion i believe :omg:k: :omg:k:

[TheFrugalGamer]

The official stance is that this forum promotes and encourages posting on old threads - old-discussing warnings should be disabled? - A big part of why I wanted to create a forum was to allow a slow form of discussion, with days or even months between each post, and maybe we are now at a point where there could be years between posts ^^

So feel free to post on any anything you like

YAAAAAY! I figured that'd be the sentiment here, but I always like to ask rather than assume.

Once an open discussion, always an open discussion i believe :omg:k: :omg:k:

Completely agree!

[dotmidi]

YAAAAAY! I figured that'd be the sentiment here, but I always like to ask rather than assume.

I think thats a good moral to have, you're completely in the right to have asked first

[sig]

The whole "no necroposting" rule on other places always seemed pretty arbitrary to me in the first place, is there a reason why a forum should want it anyway? I don't see why you should make a new thread for an old topic...

[Memory]

Considering that whole message boards are discovered through older threads that can be found on search engines, it would really be a shame to not being able to "continue" the discussion on an old thread. Although the user should have lower expectations, the participating members might have left for example.

[plantovision]

The whole "no necroposting" has always just been frustrating to me, probably because I often see situations where if you were to make a new topic, those same people would come back to harass you about duplicate topics.

[TheFrugalGamer]

The whole "no necroposting" has always just been frustrating to me, probably because I often see situations where if you were to make a new topic, those same people would come back to harass you about duplicate topics.

OMG this is also 100% true in my experience. There are some forums where people were just...very rigid about things, and it's so annoying. I feel like a lot of that was a part of the whole "nerd culture" that used to be so prevalent and insular. I'm SO glad people are more accepting and inclusive on the internet these days.

[Cele]

I get not wanting necroposting if it's like a very specific problem question that has already been dealt with in the conversation, then you could just make a new thread if you had other questions. (Not the exact same one.) But it's kind of silly if new users aren't allowed to necropost on a "What's your favourite colour?" thread.

[Memory]

I think the point is to keep people from pushing threads upwards with simple replies that don't add anything to the conversation like "I agree" or responding to someone who made that post three years ago and might feel differently or not care at all; pushing the entire topic including perhaps irrelevant information in the first post onto the front page for everyone to be confused by.

If I actually had something to add, I made good experiences simply saying "Sorry for necroposting but...". Many people can accept that.

[zephie]

i've been thinking hard about it the past year and a half and i've decided i'm all for it. big necrohead over here

[Memory]

i personally think the idea of being against necroposting is essentially conforming to social media etiquette, although idm ppl who don't like it, i get the embarrassment of someone interacting with an old post from their past, i don't like that i can't delete old art from my artfight page myself

[xXWebMasterXx_Gina]

i personally think the idea of being against necroposting is essentially conforming to social media etiquette,

There's always been negativity towards necroposting, even prior to modern social media. Granted, it does seem like its become more mainstream to ban/discourage it.

I definitely agree with everyone's sentiments here and I'm glad MelonLand encourages it! Why make a new thread when you can just resurrect an old one and continue the discussion? It also makes topics more interesting as you can see how the discussion has evolved over time!


Plus.. necromancy is the best school of magic  >:3c

[Memory]

The official stance is that this forum promotes and encourages posting on old threads - old-discussing warnings should be disabled? - A big part of why I wanted to create a forum was to allow a slow form of discussion, with days or even months between each post, and maybe we are now at a point where there could be years between posts ^^

So feel free to post on any anything you like

Thank Goodness cos I am really addicted to going through ancients posts and commenting on them